Insource or outsource? 10 considerations

July 26, 2022

It’s an assessment every investment management firm has to make: which services should you handle in house, and which should you outsource? 


Outsourcing can save time, money and other resources, but how do you decide which services to give to a third-party vendor and which you should keep within the organization?  Here are 10 questions to help guide your decision-making process.


1. What’s the size of my business?

Are you a small investment advisor shop looking to compete with bigger firms? Are you a large enough manager where entire teams and departments might be impacted? To stay viable, boutique operations need to keep their business simple and highly focused on their core competencies – outsourcing anything that doesn’t directly add value. Bigger firms have more flexibility, but many of the same considerations apply.


2. Is there enough time (and benefit) to build the necessary infrastructure internally?

It takes time to build infrastructure – a team, a department, a proficiency. It also takes time to put technology processes into place and design them to exceed the expectations of your investors. It’s essential to take each component in your business and make the determination: in or out? Can I build this in time? Can I build my staff in time? Or am I better off buying this service?


3. Am I isolating our business from valuable outside perspectives?

Outside vendors and consultants can be a great way to learn from professionals who’ve gained insight from their experience “looking under the hood” of other firms – best practices, what works, what doesn’t, etc. Rather than having, for example, an internal individual responsible for compliance (i.e., doing), consider shifting your approach so they’re instead accountable for compliance (i.e., overseeing). That way, you can bring more outside perspective into your business.


4. How can I allocate more resources to areas that give us a competitive advantage?

Your business’s competitive advantage likely won’t be compliance, information technology (IT), marketing or your customer relationship management (CRM) system. Those are important components, but your primary focus should be on your clients. When you expand, it’s advisable to rely on resources who advance your core investment management competencies (e.g., analysts, portfolio managers, etc.). Other responsibilities can be easily outsourced.


5. Where can I simplify my business to gain efficiencies and do more with less?

Whether you’re insourcing or outsourcing, your focus should always be on leveraging your firm’s strengths and improving weaknesses. This requires a model of constant reevaluation to ensure you’re not overcomplicating processes and wasting resources. Look at every aspect of the business and ask: could this be simpler? Would it be more efficient to do this ourselves or find someone to take it off our plate?


6. Can I find vendors that align with our values and goals?

Over the past decade or so, the ecosystem around supporting asset managers and funds has developed tremendously. As talent pools, vendor competition and service levels increase, it’s becoming easier to find quality support. However, it’s important to seek out companies whose management teams are on your same trajectory and who share your ethos for client service (because your clients will now be their clients.)


7. What internal obstacles exist?

Tenured staff can be wary of change. Although the firm might be moving in a certain direction, sometimes you face internal resistance. Are you upending someone’s day-to-day operating model? Are you shifting someone’s workflow? As you implement new structures and organization, pockets of individuals can hold a different view. You need to manage change internally by slowly introducing new processes and winning over the people they impact.


8. How will this decision affect clients, and am I able to reassess if necessary?

To maintain a high-level of client service, you need to be careful of what (and how) you outsource. You can’t have a situation where your service provider presents a reputational, legal or occupational risk. It often makes sense to implement your outsourcing model incrementally – adding vendors and responsibilities over time rather than through a giant, global overhaul. This gives you greater control and the ability to monitor and adjust if service starts to suffer.


9. Do I have an exit plan?

It’s important to go into a vendor relationship understanding you can end it if necessary. If you’re getting negative client feedback – perhaps where they feel the level of service is declining – that would be an immediate indicator to reassess. Be willing to “fail quickly.” That is, be willing to quit a relationship and find a replacement before too much damage is done. Sticking with an unsatisfactory vendor hoping they’ll improve over time is a bad strategy.


10. How will this decision fare into the future?

To keep your strategy future-oriented, follow these guiding principles:

  • Plan for growth. Make decisions based on where you want to be, not where you are today.
  • Plan for scrutiny. A regulator, an investor, a portfolio manager – eventually someone will analyze your choice.
  • Plan for a disaster. In a catastrophic event, how will your decision hold up?
  • Plan for a cyber event. Data breaches are a real threat, so make cybersecurity a priority.


While outsourcing has many advantages, it’s important that you ask the right questions to determine the best approach for your organization’s needs. Utilizing third-party vendors strategically can have lasting benefits and support future growth.


U.S. Bank offers customized operational solutions combined with the strength and security of a major financial institution. Visit us at to learn about our investment services solutions.

Related content

The unsung heroes of exchange-traded funds

The benefits of bundling services for Luxembourg regulated funds

Rethinking European ETFs: Strategy wrappers and a means to an end

ESG-focused investing: A closer look at the disclosure regulation

Maximizing your infrastructure finance project with a full suite trustee and agent

At your service: outsourcing loan agency work

3 innovative approaches to ESG investing in Europe

4 reasons your Luxembourg fund needs an in-market administrator

4 questions you should ask about your custodian

An investor’s guide to marketplace lending

Middle-market direct lending: Obstacles and opportunities

Easing complex transactions: Project finance case studies

3 tips to maintain flexibility in supply chain management

Bank vs. brokerage custody

Managing complex transactions: what your corporate trustee should be doing

Programme debt Q&A: U.S. issuers entering the European market

High-yield bond issuance: how to avoid 5 common pain points

Cryptocurrency custody 6 frequently asked questions

4 benefits of independent loan agents

Liquidity management: A renewed focus for European funds

Emerging trends in Europe: An outlook from multiple perspectives

Service provider due diligence and selection best practices

5 questions you should ask your custodian about outsourcing

Inherent flexibility and other benefits of collective investment trusts

Preparing for your custodian conversion

How to choose the right custodian for your managed assets

Luxembourg's thriving private debt market

High-yield bond issuance: 5 traits lawyers should look for in a service provider

Rule 2a-5 overview: Good faith determinations of fair value

The reciprocal benefits of a custodial partnership: A case study

Private equity and the full-service administrator

Top 3 considerations when selecting an IPA partner

Hybridization driving demand

Easier onboarding: What to look for in an administrator

The secret to successful service provider integration

How to maximise your infrastructure finance project

Luxembourg funds: 5 indicators of efficient onboarding

Rule 18f-4: An in-depth look at the derivative risk management program and value-at-risk

Rule 18f-4: The limited use exception

Rule 18f-4 overview: Regulatory framework changes for derivatives

Refining your search for an insurance custodian

Depositary services: A brief overview

Combined strength: Luxembourg and your fund administrator

The benefits of a full-service warehouse custodian

3 questions to ask your equity, quant and CTA fund administrator

Investment products and services are:


U.S. Bank does not guarantee the products, services or performance of its affiliates and third party providers.
Start of disclosure content

Loan approval is subject to credit approval and program guidelines. Not all loan programs are available in all states for all loan amounts. Interest rate and program terms are subject to change without notice. Mortgage, home equity and credit products are offered by U.S. Bank National Association. Deposit products are offered by U.S. Bank National Association. Member FDIC.