3 reasons governments and educational institutions should implement service fees

November 11, 2020

Use service and convenience fees on certain payments to cut costs and shore up revenues in the face of shortfalls and budget cuts.

By Veronica Correa Janssen, Head of Product Strategy, North America Vertical Markets, U.S. Bank Payment Services

 

As the COVID-19 pandemic continues to affect the economy, most organizations in the government and education sectors face budget cuts and shortfalls, creating added pressures when it comes to ensuring adequate resources are available to meet the demands during this challenging time.

Especially hard hit are state and local governments. Experts predict a $555 billion shortfall over state fiscal years 2020 to 2022. The shortfall is primarily attributed to lower tax revenues and funds redirected to addressing the more immediate crisis. Meanwhile, even optimistic estimates predict higher education institutions in the United States could suffer budgetary shortfalls of more than five percent, as international student enrollment grinds to a halt and domestic students opt to take gap years.

These conditions are forcing organizations to adapt with creative solutions for cutting costs or generating new revenue streams. One underused option is implementing service and convenience fees on certain payments, which can provide government and higher education entities with substantial cost savings that can be used to shore up against budget cuts and shortfalls.

 

What are service and convenience fees?
Service and convenience fees are widely accepted by cardholders and have been used in the U.S. to help offset payment acceptance costs for certain merchant types for over 10 years.

A service fee is a flat or percentage-based fee on transactions paid with methods other than cash or check. A convenience fee is a flat fee that helps offset costs associated with payments in card-not-present environments, such as over the phone or online. Unlike convenience fees, a service fee can be implemented for all non-cash payment methods, including in person payments.

There are many benefits of incorporating service and convenience fees into your transaction acceptance. Here are three of the most compelling reasons why it makes sense for government and educational institutions to do so:

 

1. Offset costs of accepting payments 

When working with budgets defined by taxes, federal government transfers and utility charges, optimizing payments in the public sector is essential; something we covered in a recent webinar. Similarly, budgets defined by grants and endowments mean higher-education institutions must also do more with less. In these situations, managing expenses can make a considerable difference.

Service fees and convenience fees are revenue neutral and can enable your organization to better control costs associated with accepting card payments. Like user fees, they’re a “good alternative to taxes because they are paid solely by those who request and receive those specific services or benefits."

However, knowing which type of fee and how much to charge can be a challenge.

Service fees are only available to a limited set of business types and there are specific card brand rules governing their collection. Unlike a surcharging program, one benefit of service fees is that there are no set caps or rules around the amount as long as it’s reasonable in relation to the cost of accepting the payment transaction. This gives you flexibility to leverage a fee that matches your organization’s cost model.

Conversely, convenience fees are available to all business types but are only permitted in channels that provide a convenience to the payer, such as a web portal where a user can pay from the comfort of home. Due to the predictability of utility payments, a flat fee is assessed instead of a percentage. Service fees are not allowed on utility payments.

Fortunately, you can navigate the unique requirements for your organization with a dedicated program from Elavon that helps government and educational institutions efficiently and effectively implement service and convenience fees.

 

2. Affordable way to expand payment acceptance 

In addition to supporting your organization’s operational expenses, service and convenience fees allow you to adapt to shifting consumer payment preferences. In recent years, there’s been a strong move towards digital payments including contactless cards, smartphone digital wallets and online payments – and the pandemic is only fast-forwarding this trend to cashless.

Our recently released Government Payments Insight Report, based on survey data from January 2020, shows digital payment options are the new norm, and citizen expectations are shifting accordingly. For example, we found 39% of consumers prefer to pay using a digital payment service like Apple Pay® or Google Pay®, 39% prefer paying by phone using an interactive voice response system, and 12% prefer to pay through their online bank or the biller’s web portal or mobile app. Less than half of consumers (46%) say government agencies are keeping pace with other industries when it comes to payment innovation – which includes creative ways to view and pay bills.

Still, some constituents, particularly seniors, continue to prefer paying by mail or ACH check. We found that 46% of respondents had paid a government fine, fee or service by check via postal mail within the last 12 months. This shows that choice is key when it comes to payment options.

By leveraging service fees and convenience fees, government agencies and higher education institutions can keep up with consumer demands and securely accept payments online, over the phone or by mail while offsetting processing costs. 

 

3. Improve efficiency and customer experience

Citizens rely on government agencies to provide vital services to their community, and students rely on colleges to provide them with formative learning experiences. Supplying these services requires these organizations to collect payments efficiently and consistently from the people they serve.

But paying for these services can be a hassle for consumers, who often face long lines at the DMV or school registrar’s office, resulting in negative customer service issues. Fortunately, as new technologies emerge and become more widely used, government agencies and educational institutions have ongoing opportunities to improve the customer experience.

Service and convenience fees are part of the way forward, allowing your organization to operate more efficiently by outsourcing fee management. By making it affordable to accept payments that minimize or eliminate touchpoints, service and convenience fees also help you boost customer experience and keep your customers and employees safe.

 

As your organization pivots to address the challenges of the pandemic, it’s important to consider solutions that help you cut costs today while making strategic investments for tomorrow. Learn more about how service and convenience fees can help. 

Related content

How to open and invest in a 529 plan

Managing the rising costs of payment acceptance with service fees

How grandparents can contribute to college funds instead of buying gifts

4 restaurant models that aren’t dine-in

CFO survey: A shifting focus on ESG in business

Tap-to-pay: Modernizing fare payments pays off for transit agencies and riders

How I did it: Deciding whether to buy an RV

CFO report: Driving growth via new business models and technology

CFO insights: Leading the recovery for sustainable growth

How I kicked my online shopping habit and got my spending under control

Navigate changing consumer behavior with service fees

Trends in economics, immigration and mobility policy

Ways prepaid cards disburse government funds to the unbanked

How to stay positive when searching for a job: advice from a U.S. Bank goals coach

First-time homebuyer’s guide to getting a mortgage

Opening a business on a budget during COVID-19

Modernizing fare payment without leaving any riders behind

Access, flexibility and simplicity: How governments can modernize payments to help their citizens

What’s your financial IQ? Game-night edition

Parent checklist: Preparing for college

What government officials should know about real-time payments

Using 529 plans for K-12 tuition

A passion for fashion: How this student works the gig economy

6 pandemic money habits keep for long term

Webinar: Mortgage basics: How much house can you afford?

Tips for navigating a medical hardship when you’re unable to work

Student checklist: Preparing for college

The A to Z’s of college loan terms

Co-signing 101: Applying for a loan with co-borrower

5 things to know before accepting a first job offer

Webinar: Bank Notes: College cost comparison

Is a home equity loan for college the right choice for your student

How to apply for federal student aid through the FAFSA

Be careful when taking out student loans

Solutions banks can offer during the COVID-19 pandemic

Improve government payments with electronic billing platforms

How jumbo loans can help home buyers and your builder business

Webinar: Mindset Matters: How to practice mindful spending

Flexibility remains essential for public sector workforces

Post-pandemic fraud prevention lessons for local governments

How business owners are managing during the supply chain crisis

Prioritizing payroll during the COVID-19 pandemic

How a travel clothing retailer is staying true to its brand values

How community gave life to lifestyle boutique Les Sol

How a group fitness studio made the most of online workouts

How Wenonah Canoe is making a boom in business last

How a bar trivia company went digital during COVID-19

Safeguarding the payment experience through contactless

How this photography business persevered through tough times

3 reasons governments and educational institutions should implement service fees

ABCs of ARP: Answers to American Rescue Plan questions for counties

4 tips for protecting your business against Coronavirus-related scams

Government agency credit card programs and PCI compliance

COVID-19 safety recommendations: Are you ready to reopen?

Higher education and the cashless society: Latest trends

Government billing survey: The digital transformation of the payment experience

How to accept credit card payments without transaction fees

Webinar: Economic, political and policy insights

Start of disclosure content

Loan approval is subject to credit approval and program guidelines. Not all loan programs are available in all states for all loan amounts. Interest rate and program terms are subject to change without notice. Mortgage, home equity and credit products are offered by U.S. Bank National Association. Deposit products are offered by U.S. Bank National Association. Member FDIC.

U.S. Bank is not responsible for and does not guarantee the products, services or performance of U.S. Bancorp Investments, Inc.