The stagflation threat
With the risk of recession, in the background, Bovino and other economic analysts speculate that for the U.S. at least, stagflation could be a more challenging concern. Stagflation, the simultaneous rise in inflation and unemployment rates, is an unusual occurrence. “We experienced significant stagflation in the late 1970s and early 1980s,” says Bovino. “The numbers at that time were far more challenging than what exists today.”
Between 1979 and 1981, the annual inflation rate, as measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI), topped 10%. In November 1982, the nation’s unemployment rate peaked at 10.8%. 2 “At that time, it forced the Fed to raise interest rates dramatically, sending the U.S. into a deep recession,” notes Bovino. It’s a scenario most analysts feel could be painful and should be avoided.
Stagflation is a significant monetary policy challenge for the Fed. While the U.S. central bank’s dual mandate is to maintain moderate inflation and full employment, its policy tools are in tension during an environment where both inflation and unemployment are high and rising. To curb surging inflation, the Fed typically raises the federal funds target rate, which guides overnight lending between large financial institutions. This was the core of Fed monetary policy in 2022 and 2023 as U.S. inflation surged to more than 9%. When a weaker economy results in higher unemployment, the Fed typically lowers the fed funds rate, similar to what it did in early 2020 as the COVID pandemic began. “When both inflation and unemployment rise, the Fed faces a dilemma in how to respond effectively,” says Bovino. “The Fed’s toolkit to lower inflation also weakens the jobs market, and vice-versa. This is one of the challenges of a stagflation environment.”