Your gateway to organizational growth
Explore related insights or solutions.
Article
Higher acquisition financing costs demand a disciplined, returns-focused M&A strategy.
A rigorous corporate development strategy empowers the C-suite to deploy capital with confidence to drive shareholder value.
Creative deal structures such as earn-outs, seller financing, and staged acquisitions preserve flexibility and align risk with reward.
Strong governance frameworks and aligned incentive plans ensure the C-suite is held accountable for M&A strategy.
Rising acquisition financing costs are making life more challenging for dealmakers. Data from PwC suggests that the value of global M&A will increase in 2026, with the higher frequency of “megadeals” driving this trend. Yet deal volumes are expected to fall by around 13% year over year. Businesses worldwide are rethinking M&A strategies as higher interest rates and fierce competition for capital – especially from the U.S. tech giants looking to fund investment in artificial intelligence – take their toll.
But according to our M&A trends research, appetite for acquisitions remains healthy in the U.S. In the U.S. Bank Fall 2026 CFO Insights Report, 57% of finance leaders said they were more likely to make acquisitions in the next 12 months than they were in the past year, up from 49% in the spring.
Even so, buyers still need to proceed with caution, says Ryan Hutchins, executive vice president and head of strategy and business development for the Institutional Client Group at U.S. Bank. “In this environment, companies have less room for error if an acquisition underperforms,” he says. “That makes it particularly important to pressure-test valuations, challenge the underlying assumptions, and understand how the business and balance sheet would perform across a range of scenarios before committing capital.”
A well-defined corporate development strategy helps create that discipline by establishing clear acquisition priorities and investment criteria before an opportunity arises. “Experienced advisors can add an external market perspective, challenge assumptions, and help management teams determine not only how to execute a transaction, but also when it makes sense to walk away,” Hutchins says.
That kind of discipline marks a shift from recent years. When credit was more readily available and interest rates were lower, business leaders could stretch on valuations to improve their chances of closing a deal. M&A remains a critical element of corporate development strategy, but today, buyers and their advisors must be able to justify the price they pay.
JT Herman, global head of M&A at U.S. Bancorp BTIG, says the current cost of capital is not excessive by historical standards. Rather, he suggests, dealmakers may have had it too good for much of the past two decades. Policymakers had kept interest rates low to protect the economy from shocks such as the financial crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic. But today, acquisitive companies are reconsidering their M&A strategies in the context of a sustained higher interest rate environment.
“Corporate boards are dealing with both higher interest rates and elevated levels of uncertainty and volatility,” Herman says. “That’s what explains recent M&A trends, with a lower absolute number of deals, and the very largest transactions representing a greater percentage of deal volume. Businesses are wrestling with some difficult questions about how events are going to affect them, both domestically and in global markets.”
Herman adds that acquisition financing is still available at costs that look reasonable by long-term standards. The key will be a change of buyer and seller mindset. Higher financing costs necessitate a shift from opportunistic dealmaking to a disciplined, returns-focused corporate development strategy.
With acquisition financing costs now rising, it’s more important than ever to pursue transactions through the lens of a well-rounded, holistic corporate development strategy, rather than dealmaking opportunism.
“If you can’t articulate that strategy today, now is the time to go back to the drawing board,” suggests Herman. “Figure out what it is that makes you unique and what will preserve and extend your competitive advantage in your sector. Then, stay true to that as your North Star, making acquisitions or divestitures accordingly.”
The new strategy must also pay attention to balance-sheet strength. Does the business have the spare capital it will need if the right deal comes up? If not, it may be wise to augment finances through equity, debt, or divestitures. That way, deal conversations can focus on whether an opportunity is right for the business, rather than whether the business can afford to take it.
“While sellers inevitably prefer a straightforward transaction, with a purchase price that meets their expectations paid up front, they may be prepared to accept a different structure if they’re confident in the business plan and it gets the deal done at an acceptable valuation.”
Management teams also need access to data and intelligence to support assessment of a potential transaction. Instinctive dealmaking is difficult to reconcile with strategic M&A activity. Centralized financial data provides the foundation for a more analytical approach.
Companies with a well-planned corporate development strategy know which attributes they’re looking for in a potential acquisition to boost their growth ambitions. They’re also able to execute on those acquisitions when they arise, irrespective of broader M&A trends.
Likewise, boards should be prepared to say no to deal opportunities that aren’t a good strategic fit, or that can’t be secured for a sensible price. Knowing when to walk away is just as important as knowing how and when to clinch a deal.
A more disciplined approach to dealmaking demands scrutiny of M&A valuations. Boards must base the business case for an acquisition on realistic projections, rather than optimistic assumptions. That requires them to be more rigorous in scenario planning and forecasting and to adjust their own judgment and weighting in determining a “good deal” for shareholders, suggests Herman. “It’s going to be important to adjust assumptions about factors that ultimately drive long-term free cash flow generation,” he says.
That advice applies to both buyers and sellers. In a challenging environment, the former would be unwise to commit to an acquisition that looks difficult to justify with realistic models and forecasts.
But sellers, including those looking to divest assets as part of their M&A strategy, must also be hardheaded in terms of M&A valuations. Otherwise, they risk slipping into a valuation gap that demands they deliver scarcely attainable financial performance in a likely futile attempt to justify the higher price.
Even when a deal is the right strategic fit, closing it at an acceptable value can require flexibility as well as discipline. It may be possible to structure a deal so that some of the risk is shared with the seller.
Seller financing, where the seller allows the buyer to pay some of the purchase price in installments, is one option. Such structures align the seller’s interests with the future success of the company, as they may only realize the full purchase price if it continues to generate sufficient cash flows.
Earn-out clauses, where the existing ownership team stays with the business post-acquisition, provide similar alignment. Owners typically receive some of the purchase price up front, with the rest payable only if the business hits agreed targets. Again, the buyer is protected if the business underperforms post-deal, and the seller is incentivized to help the business deliver on its growth plan.
“While sellers inevitably prefer a straightforward transaction, with a purchase price that meets their expectations paid up front, they may be prepared to accept a different structure if they’re confident in the business plan and it gets the deal done at an acceptable valuation,” says Herman.
There are several variations on this approach in M&A structuring. For example, a seller may offer a loan, known as a seller’s note, allowing the buyer to defer part of the purchase price. The buyer repays the loan, often from funds generated by the acquired business, typically with interest, over an agreed period, without having to raise equity. Alternatively, the deal may include an earn-out, under which the seller receives one or more additional payments if the business meets agreed performance targets. These payments can be dramatic if the business substantially exceeds expectations.
But deal structure will always require careful negotiation, with both buyers and sellers keen to minimize their exposure to risk. Earn-out payments can also be linked to profitability measures such as earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) or net income. These measures may give buyers more room to influence the financial results that determine how much the seller receives. Alternatively, payments can be linked to measures such as units sold, which sellers may prefer because they are less affected by the buyer’s accounting decisions.
On some deals, it may be particularly challenging to share risk. In certain sectors, a very large chunk of potential deal value may be tied up in a specific outcome. For example, this might depend on whether a biotech company receives approval for a new drug, or whether an innovative technology secures patent approval. It may make sense to structure such deals so a significant share of the M&A valuation is payable only if a positive outcome is achieved within an agreed time frame.
The final piece of the puzzle is governance. Every business focused on growth must weigh its appetite for strategic acquisitions against the need for balance-sheet discipline. The pressure to maintain earnings, particularly for businesses in a quarterly reporting cycle, only adds to the difficulty of making such calculations. But strong frameworks and guardrails help keep everyone honest.
The board has a critical role to play. Engaged directors are ready and equipped to ask demanding questions about the business’s overall M&A strategy. And they’re able to interrogate the business cases for individual transactions, ensuring the CEO and other executives maintain a disciplined focus on strategic goals.
The structure of compensation is an important consideration here. Management incentive plans tied to loose growth metrics may not encourage financial discipline. If executives stand to benefit simply because the enterprise is bigger than before, there’s less reason for them to focus on broader corporate development strategy. Incentivization should therefore be built around returns on capital – even more so now that acquisition financing costs are increasing.
“Accountability is everything,” concludes Herman. “When management teams communicate clearly and are fully accountable to the board and to shareholders more broadly, their focus remains on performance, rather than empire building. That ensures a strategic approach to dealmaking that moves the business forward with confidence, even in a more complex M&A environment.”
In a higher-cost environment, the right deal is one that fits both your strategy and your balance sheet. Contact your U.S. Bank relationship manager to discuss how U.S. Bank can support your corporate development strategy, from acquisition financing to capital planning.
Leading organizations are using stronger forecasting and better data to improve resilience and build the agility to act when conditions change.
Whether you need to enhance your long-term capital structure or fund expansion and operating expenditures, we’re here to help.
Unlock timely, actionable strategies and perspectives from U.S. Bank experts — delivered straight to your inbox.